Friday, January 25, 2013

Housing Crisis Forces Young Couples Out Of Inner City

More evidence has emerged about the difficulties facing people trying to enter the property market for the first time.

An international  housing affordability survey has found that Auckland real estate is severely unaffordable by international standards.

Anecdotal evidence continues to mount, with many real estate agents recounting hard-luck stories about young couples trying to enter into the market.

Young couple Magda Narses and Jason Belisarius have been looking for a property for over six months.

Magda said they could not find anything remotely affordable.

“It’s soul-destroying”, said Magda. “For the last four months we have gone to dozens of open homes, and gone through I don’t know how many house viewings. It’s hopeless and depressing.”

Jason, who works part-time at his local Countdown supermarket after he finishes school, said he thought the rules were stacked against young people trying to get ahead.

“We’re competing against property investors who know all the tricks,” said Jason. “More than once we've put an offer on a place, only to be trumped at the last minute by someone buying their third or fourth property.”

Magda and Jason say they have a good income, earning more than most other seventeen year-olds they know.

But Magda said it makes no difference, and they cannot find a property within their price bracket.

“ I've lost track of the number of places in Ponsonby, Grey Lynn and Herne Bay we have looked at.  The asking prices are stupid. We made an offer last week on a nice old renovated villa in St Mary’s Bay with four spacious bedrooms and a sea view, but the owner just laughed at us. Some property investor ended up outbidding us.”

“I thought two hundred thousand was a fair price,” said Jason. “Even that was a real stretch, but Mum said she’d go guarantor.”

Magda and Jason accept that their dream of owning a first home in a pleasant and leafy inner-city Auckland suburb may not come to pass, and they blame the government for its lack of action on the housing front.

“Ponsonby Road is where the vibe is at,” said Jason. “It’s where I want to be. Why won’t the government do something?”

Magda said she had now accepted that they would need to look further out from the centre of town.

“We've had to start searching in Westmere and Mt Eden, and Jason reckons we should also be prepared to consider Pt. Chevalier,” she said.

“But they’re so far from the centre of town. How are we meant to get in to see a show or a gig in less than ten minutes?

"How do people live like this?"

Real Estate agent Justin D’Croix said that Jason and Magda had unrealistic expectations and needed to look beyond the inner city.

“It's true that there is a housing crisis in Auckland, with not enough properties within the entry-level price bracket. But there is still some affordable housing out west and in some parts of South Auckland,” said Mr D’Croix.

"In Massey, for instance, some houses are going for under three hundred thousand dollars. They're not pretty, but it's a start.

“People just have to accept that getting on the property ladder usually means starting at the bottom rung.

But Magda says she cannot live in Massey.

“West Auckland? Oh my god! I would rather die,” she said.

Green Party housing spokesperson Holly Walker agrees.

“It’s a disgrace. Do we really expect young people like Magda to have to die? The government must do something!”

14 comments:

  1. what's meant to be the message here? that there's no home affordability problem? People have just got to wait to get older and pay whatever the failed market demands?

    You know, we're not all lawyers with big pay cheques. The problem is there's not enough affordable homes to go around and even 'affordable' is unaffordable for many families.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very good. Now re-read the piece.

      Delete
    2. I don't get it. If the middle-class move out to the working class suburbs because the prices there are now middle class where do the working class go to buy houses?

      It seems to be an endorsement of the bubble. The gradual and painless easing of which, by the way, is the real rationale behind affordable housing policies. The gains for individuals is just how it has to be sold.

      Alternatively we could wait until demographics bursts the bubble and hundreds of thousands of Kiwis have their main asset written down or, worse, find themselves owing the (Australian) bank more than their house is worth.

      I also think the snide dig at the greens is below you, Scott.

      Delete
    3. A post mocking the unrealistic expectations of some people is not the same thing as an endorsement of the housing bubble.

      I also think the snide dig at the greens is below you, Scott.

      If I'd chosen the Labour housing spokesperson nobody would have said a thing. Every time I post something even mildly critical of the Greens someone tells me off like I've been a naughty boy. Interesting.

      Delete
    4. A post mocking the unrealistic expectations of some people is not the same thing as an endorsement of the housing bubble.

      It functions as such because it emphasises a small negative aspect of the issue at the expense of the much bigger real problem.

      It's reminiscent of the the commentaries from the right that focus on the tiny numbers of bneficiaries' who drink and smoke and leave their children in pub carparks.

      And there's lots of reasons to be critical of the greens and ways to do it. It's just the way you've picked is snide, and below you.

      Delete
    5. I'm not sure where you are coming from. My post started with a link to an international survey providing evidence that housing affordability is a major issue. And the real estate agent in the post acknowledges the problem. Did you decide not to read those parts?

      I predict the Greens will survive my "snide" attack. I'm not particularly anti-Green. Some of my best friends etc...

      Delete
  2. It is a Byzantine tale, is the property market.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Are you kidding on what's the message?
    The message is first home buyers need to work their way up into the best areas, media is full of these morons bemoaning it being a million bucks to live in a good suburb.
    So it bloody should be, and as for 'I'll move to Australia because it's unaffordable here'? Equivalent suburbs in Melbourne and Sydney are more expensive then in NZ.The cheap houses these Muppets are buying are in the Aussie equivalent of Flatbush and Henderson

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha ha, nothing wrong with Henderson peeps. We bought in Te Atatu Sth and still manage to stay alive.

      Delete
    2. 7 years on the Rosebank Penisula and still alive, hey you can buy a 4 bed on 700m for 450k

      Delete
  4. Lovely piece of satire Scott. Y'know if the lawyering gig turns tits up, you could always write press releases for Labour

    ReplyDelete
  5. They are obviously using the wrong agent!

    http://martynbradburyrealty.com/Welcome.html

    ReplyDelete
  6. no shortage of homes under $300k in Manurewa, Papakura or Mangere East & Central.

    That was a nice bit of satire, Scott you are quite talented.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Good piece :)
    Frightening irony deficit in many of your responders...
    The American dumbing down continues apace

    ReplyDelete

I welcome comments, but I ask commenters to follow a few simple rules:

1. I delete anonymous comments. Please use either a name or moniker. I am not asking anyone to reveal their secret identity. Just don't call yourself "Anonymous".
2. Please don't abuse or defame others.
3. Moronic or nonsensical comments may be deleted.
4. I don't often exercise the heavy hand of censorship, but I do reserve the right to delete any comment I don't like, for any reason.